How to Increase the Size of Donor Gifts with Fundraising Letters

Do you want your donors to give more, do youOne way to increase the size of average donations is
want them to give more often, or do you wantto ask each donor to give a gift of the same size as
more of your donors to give?their last gift. If Samantha's last gift was $150, ask
If your answer is "all of the above," here are somefor $150 this time. If Brad recently mailed you a gift
tested ways to increase the size of donor gifts usingof $75 (which is an amount higher than $45 but lower
fundraising letters.than $100 on your ask string), ask Brad for a gift of
Ask for specific amounts$75 in your next appeal letter.
Stating the sizes of gifts that donors can make helpsCustomized asks like this are costly in time (database
to overcome their inertia and prevents them frommanipulation) and production (customized printing for
having to think up a gift amount (which may be tooeach reply device or letter), but the results can be
small) on their own.spectacular. Again, this is worth testing.
Increase the size of your smallest suggestedMail special appeals to major donors
donationDonors or member who send you gifts of
If you feature an ask string in your reply device,£1,000 or more should never be told: "Your
increase the size of the smallest suggested gift, likegift of £25, £50 or even
this.£100--whatever you can manage--will be much
Before:appreciated right now." In the same way that you
 $20  $45  $100should never ask a £100 donor for
 Other $______________£1,000, you should never ask a £1,000
After:donor for £100. Asking major donors for
 $25  $45  $100major gift amounts will increase the size of average
 Other $______________individual donations.
This simple adjustment will likely translate into largerUpgrade donors each year to cover inflation
average gifts, although your response rate may dropAnother way to increase the size of donations is to
slightly.invite your donors, perhaps once a year, to increase
Circle the desired donationtheir gift amount by a given percentage to cover the
On the reply device that donors mail back with theircost of inflation. Example: "If you can manage to
gift, circle the second and higher amount. Beneathincrease your gift by 4% this year, from $50 to $52,
your circle, handwrite: "Your gift of this amount willthat will help us keep pace with the cost of inflation."
make a big difference."Reduce your expenses
Ask based on each donor's giving historyThis step will not increase your gross revenue but it
In the above example, you see that if you askwill increase your net revenue. Reducing your costs
donors to give a donation of $20, $45 or $100, theyfor design, printing, lettershop, postage and other
are likely to make a donation of $20, $45 or $100.tasks--even if only by a few cents per package--can
But what about your donors who are capable ofboost your net revenue without much extra effort.
giving at higher levels? What about your donors whoJust make sure the quality of your appeal letters and
sent you larger gifts than the ones suggested onpackages does not decline.
your reply device?